Blogger Q&A - And The Valley Shook
This week's Blogger Q&A comes from And the Valley Shook, SBNation's LSU blog. My responses to theirs should go up soon. What do you think of their prediction at the end?
1. When the Tigers signed Russell Sheppard, I figured that he would win the quarterback job from Jordan Jefferson. Then he was immediately moved to wide receiver. Considering that Jefferson isn't exactly lighting it up, why doesn't Miles give Sheppard a chance to show what he's got? Is he really that bad? Also, discuss how LSU uses Sheppard currently and any plans to use him differently later.
I think way too much attention is paid to new recruits. They are like the shiny new toy under the Christmas tree, and we want to play with them right away. Even in his recruiting videos, Shepard didn’t look like a polished passer, but let’s put that aside for a second. What SEC quarterback has EVER come in and played at a high level as a true freshman? It just doesn’t happen.
Miles realizes he has a great talent in Shep, and he’s getting him the ball however he can, but right now, that great talent does not mean great quarterback. In fact, nothing he’s done makes me believe he could be a quarterback, as it looks like his future is at running back once he adds some muscle.
The guy who needs the chance is Jordan Jefferson. The guy is only 19, a true sophomore, and he’s already performing quite well. He’s not among the SEC elite, but he very well could be if he ends up being a three year starter. You can’t coach experience.
Rahim Alem is both our best defensive lineman and our worst. He’s a ferocious pass rusher and even when he wasn’t racking up sacks, he was getting to the QB and forcing him out of the pocket. He’s a high energy player and he’s got the dreaded "endless motor". Here’s the rub, he’s reckless as hell and frequently forgets assignments. He’s just awful in run coverage, often spending short yardage situations on the bench, and he’s susceptible to screen passes. A shifty back like McCluster absolutely terrifies me.
Which means you should still fear the interior of our line. Drake Nevis leads a solid unit, and it’s no accident LSU has been so good on goalline situations this season. We may not be getting lots of sacks, but we do usually win the push at the line.
3. Who is your best offensive player about whom no one is talking? Defensive?
Richard Dickson is so forgotten that he’s no longer getting the ball. I just don’t know why he’s disappeared. Actually, I do. Crowton has completely abandoned the middle of the field in order to avoid interceptions, and that’s where tight ends make their living. I expect him to continue to be a non-factor.
The less-hyped guy to worry about is Terrance Toliver. Brandon LaFell is a great receiver and rightfully draws the most attention from defenses, which opens up opportunities for the big and smooth Toliver. He can beat you downfield and he can also run you over. He’s probably the next in the line of great LSU receivers.
On defense, everyone is talking about Patrick Peterson, for obvious reasons. He’s awesome. Simply awesome. But the guys who have keyed our defensive resurgence is our linebacking trio of Kelvin Sheppard, Perry Riley, and Harry Coleman. LSU has lacked big time linebackers for a long time, which is surprising for a team that has been so good defensively.
If I had to single one as the guy no one is talking about, it’s Harry Coleman. Last year, he was a safety, but Chavis shifted him to linebacker, in a move a lot people questioned. Coleman has absolutely thrived, even with some added bulk to his frame. He could have been a star safety in our excellent secondary, but instead he took one for the team and moved to the problem area of linebacker and made it a team strength. I love guys like that. Coleman might be my favorite player just for his commitment to the team.
4. For argument's sake, let's assume that LSU loses to Ole Miss this weekend. Is Les Miles on the hotseat for finishing the regular season 9-3 and third in the West? As an Ole Miss fan, I can't even fathom being dissatisfied with that, but I understand that expectations of grandeur are important for a program with BCS National Championships under their belt.
This is where I get to say how much I hate our own fanbase right now. There is a vocal minority of fans who want Miles on the hot seat NOW. It would be a mistake to say Miles is being compared to Saban, he is in fact being compared to the Saban Myth, a mythical coach who had every player prepared, never made a wrong decision, and never lost a game apparently. Miles cannot live up to the Saban Myth. No coach can.
The preseason expectation was 9-3 or else. Miles seems likely to reach that, which won’t in any way silence his critics. Neither will winning the next two games and then the Cap One Bowl. If LSU finishes 11-2, I absolutely guarantee it will in no way silence his detractors. There is absolutely nothing that will except multiple national titles and undefeated seasons, which is a ridiculous standard. Miles, simply put, is the most successful coach in LSU history. How a vocal portion of our fanbase is treating him is absolutely shameful. Frankly, it’s also self-defeating. What coach would want the LSU job if we run off a guy who, in five years, has had 4 10-win season (possibly), 2 SEC West titles, 2 BCS bowls, 1 SEC title, 1 national title, and guided the team through the hurricane disaster year during his first year with class and grace? That resume should make you a legend. If that’s not good enough, what is?
5. What's your prediction for Saturday's game? Give a predicted score and explain how it will play out.
We hate predictions at ATVS because the game is unpredictable. But, since you asked, it’s only polite to make my best guess.
I think McCluster will have another big day. Not Tennessee big, but I do think he is going to clear 100 yards easy. What I don’t see is Ole Miss getting it’s passing game going against the LSU defense. Peterson will shut down Shay Hodge and McCluster will have to be the offense by himself.
On the other side of the ball, it all depends on how effective Jordan Jefferson is. If he can play reasonably well on his ankle, he’s a ruthlessly efficient passer. I’m still concerned about our run game, but Keiland looked comfortable as The Man. Our offense will sputter like usual, and then explode for a big drive or two, also like usual.
The difference, as always for LSU this season, will be special teams. LSU negates all returns in its kick game and our returners are, well, pretty darn good. LSU wins the field position battle which will key a close victory. Afterwards, people will call it lucky. LSU 23-21
0 recs |
25 comments
Comments
Answer to Question 1
Peyton Manning.
Thank you, good night.
by Rebels7 on Nov 19, 2009 12:38 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Be honest...
The exception, not the rule.
ex; Brent Schaeffer also @ Tennessee.
by David. on Nov 19, 2009 1:01 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
The reason I'm not totally buying that,
and I think it’s a legitimate thing to say, is that Shepard arrived at LSU in January and was largely thought to be a top ten overall player coming out of high school. Then he couldn’t even COMPETE with a true sophomore who had been on campus for a semester?
Red Cup Rebellion - An Ole Miss Blog
Blame the Baptists.
by Juco All-American on Nov 19, 2009 1:04 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
He said "ever"
All I needed was one example. It’s called reading comprehension.
by Rebels7 on Nov 19, 2009 1:31 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Ok, granted
So all a player needs to do to compete as a freshman QB in the SEC is be one of the greatest QB’s of all time.
In the end, I don’t think Shep will be a QB at all
Fake Pundit. Real Fan.
http://www.andthevalleyshook.com
by Poseur on Nov 19, 2009 3:32 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Classic LSU douche
I responded to his comment. You make a new argument, because you have no response. Read the original statement that I commented on, All-Star.
by Rebels7 on Nov 19, 2009 3:43 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Jesus, lighten up
No need to go straight to the douche (and maybe you need one).
To review:
I SAY: Shep isn’t ready. Playing freshmen at QB is a bad idea. Can you think of any of them that were ever good?
YOU SAY: Peyton Manning.
I SAY: Shep ain’t Peyton Manning.
YOU SAY: Douchebag.
Seriously, WTF? Yes, if you have Peyton Manning, you may ignore most general guidelines. But the list of failures at QB as freshmen is much longer than the successes. You’re trying to change the argument to “I can name a successful freshman QB” from the overall argument of “starting freshman at QB in the SEC is a bad idea”. Hell, if we’re gonna mention Chris Leake, why not Jordan friggin’ Jefferson? You know, the guy who actually is the starter?
Has anyone seen anything from Shepard to make them think he has any chance of duplicating Peyton Manning’s career? Really?
Fake Pundit. Real Fan.
http://www.andthevalleyshook.com
by Poseur on Nov 19, 2009 6:19 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Here, I'll even help you, Chief
“What SEC quarterback has EVER come in and played at a high level as a true freshman? It just doesn’t happen.”
Hence my response.
by Rebels7 on Nov 19, 2009 3:44 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Poseur,
Chris Leake wasn’t bad as a freshman.
I think the bigger question here is how often does an SEC school start a true freshman at quarterback. We don’t have a lot of examples to go by because teams in the SEC just don’t do it.
Red Cup Rebellion - An Ole Miss Blog
Blame the Baptists.
by Juco All-American on Nov 19, 2009 3:51 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Teams in general just don't do it.
That’s because it’s a bad idea.
Red Cup Rebellion - Changing the Culture of Ole Miss Athletics
Take a picture, trick.
by The Ghost of Jay Cutler on Nov 19, 2009 4:33 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
you guys calling for Russell Shephard need to watch his highlights
I think the player he compares to best is Pat White. Do you think Pat White would have come on to team w/ a passing attack and throwing the ball around as a freshman. No way.
Russell Shephard has absolutely not impressed me w/ his arm. The guy is a dynamic player, and would be lighting it up in Rich Rod’s offense as a runner. But LSU doesn’ t want to ruin this kid’s confidence by making him throw so much when he can’t do it in my opinion.
Also, you aren’t giving enough credit to JJ. He isn’t a strength of the team yet, but he is on the cusp of becoming a strength of the team. His improvement throughout the year has been steady.
by Zandor435 on Nov 19, 2009 1:24 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
I'm not calling for him
I just wondered what ATVS thought about the use of him so far.
I agree that he probably doesn’t have an adequate arm.
As for JJ, was it his 96 yards passing against Florida that convinced you he’s on the cusp of being a strength or his 163 yards against Tulane (a game he stayed in until the fourth quarter for some reason).
Red Cup Rebellion - An Ole Miss Blog
Blame the Baptists.
by Juco All-American on Nov 19, 2009 1:30 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
From Brandon Bolden's Facebook status:
Yesterday: Brandon Bolden: “lol i neva been so mad but its cool jus mo fuel to my fire LSU its a pissed off 34 this weekend and theres no makin it betta so approach wit caution that goes for everybody”
Alright now, someone at LSU has done pissed in Brandon’s Rebelos. I haven’t read any news articles where anyone calls him or Ole Miss out in a bad way so I wonder if LSU fans are now calling and texting players?
Today: Brandon Bolden: “Talent alone won’t make you a success. Neither will being in the right place at the right time, unless you are ready. The most important question is ‘Are you Ready’?” -Johnny Carson
Indeed Brandon, indeed. Go kill you some Tiger!
Ole Miss football 2009. I shaved my balls for this?
by BimBamOleMissByDamn on Nov 19, 2009 2:55 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
I disagree.
I think he was very reasonable.
Red Cup Rebellion - An Ole Miss Blog
Blame the Baptists.
by Juco All-American on Nov 19, 2009 4:50 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I am neither agreeing or disagreeing with you
but every time someone talks bad about a blogger from an opposing team y’all come to their rescue and kiss their ass. I don’t get it. Does SB Nation ask that y’all play nice in the sandbox?
by Hunter C. on Nov 19, 2009 5:09 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I know for a fact they make no real money from doing this.
well think about it this way. Disagreeing with the viewpoints of another blogger is one thing but calling him a tool bag is simply ad hominem and does not do much to qualify his ability to analyze the game.
WW and Ghost are unapologetically peckerwoods butt their analysis is usually pretty good. Hence, saying they are dicks is valid but it would not be logical to discredit their ability to discuss football.
Poseur (or however the fuck you spell it) has been for the most part reasonable albeit a bit homerish toward LSU. But then again, that should be expected seeing as how he runs a Red Stick-centered blog. It isn’t like he is a Mudbug or Gonzo, those guys are tools.
Hyundai, it's the new motherfuckin Lexis
by Hoyt Brumley on Nov 19, 2009 6:46 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I must say...
… I really enjoy a debate over my toolbag-ishness. If you’d like, I have an ex-wife who would gladly witness for the prosecution.
Fake Pundit. Real Fan.
http://www.andthevalleyshook.com
by Poseur on Nov 19, 2009 10:59 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
The reason is that it makes us look
like pussies to host a HATE WEEK while not being able to take a bit of homerish ribbing from the opposition in stride. We have picked on Poseur before but he ain’t a bad guy as far as I can tell. And frankly put, there aren’t many rival bloggers who post here that I don’t like because most of them aren’t morons.
Red Cup Rebellion - Changing the Culture of Ole Miss Athletics
Take a picture, trick.
by The Ghost of Jay Cutler on Nov 20, 2009 7:07 AM EST via mobile up reply actions 0 recs
Never the less,
FUCK LSU.
Ole Miss football 2009. I shaved my balls for this?
by BimBamOleMissByDamn on Nov 20, 2009 10:49 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I thought he was fine.
We obviously have different definitions of tool bag.
by unidentified black male on Nov 19, 2009 8:20 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Yeah
the definition is easy, those that speak and live in France.
Fuck ’em
Hyundai, it's the new motherfuckin Lexis
by Hoyt Brumley on Nov 20, 2009 12:44 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Jefferson
Considering that Jefferson isn’t exactly lighting it up, why doesn’t Miles give Sheppard a chance to show what he’s got?
I agree that Jefferson isn’t lighting it up but he’s not exactly struggling either. He’s actually 4th in the SEC in passing efficiency (among full-time QBs). He’s struggled here and there, but he’s been good more often than not.
by amiznit on Nov 19, 2009 6:29 PM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 













